How To Reheat A Deep Dish Pizza

Deep dish pizza originated in Chicago but has become well known and loved beyond just the windy city. Invented by Ike Sewell and Ric Riccardo, this fun spin on the Italian classic was first served to the public in 1943 from their small Chicago restaurant, Pizzeria Uno.

Since the deep dish pizza’s debut, it has gained massive popularity, becoming a norm for pizza shops all over to serve to their customers. Thankfully, this dish is just as good when reheated as it is freshly made.

Deep dish pizza can be reheated slice by slice or as a whole pie. The conventional oven, toaster oven, and microwave can all reheat your deep dish pizza in no time. 

The next time you find yourself with some leftover deep dish pizza, be sure to save it to enjoy later rather than letting it go to waste. This pizza is very easy to pop in your reheating method of choice and sink your teeth into only minutes later.

Methods That You Can Use To Reheat Deep Dish Pizza

Reheating deep dish pizza is very similar to reheating a thin crust pie, though the stove becomes an additional option. All methods listed are sure to bring life back into your pizza and satisfy just as well as when you took that first bite of a fresh deep dish pizza slice.

Reheating A Deep Dish Pizza In The Oven

Reheating a deep dish pizza in the oven guarantees that it will remain fresh and delicious through the heating process. This method will keep your crust soft and doughy while also keeping your toppings high quality.

One great thing about the oven method of reheating a deep dish pizza is that you can heat a large or small quantity. The oven can easily fit an entire deep dish pizza pie, making this an ideal method for when you are preparing a larger portion.

The only drawback of reheating a deep dish pizza in the oven is that it takes the most time out of all methods. You will have to wait for the oven to preheat, which adds additional time from pulling it out to cook and taking a bite of it. 

Related Posts  How to Reheat Indian Food: Tips and Tricks for Delicious Leftovers

If you choose to reheat your deep dish pizza in the oven, you will surely be more than satisfied with the delicious results. To do so:

  1. Preheat your oven to 325 degrees fahrenheit with a pizza pan already inside of it.
  2. Allow your oven to heat the pan up for about five minutes.
  3. Remove the pan with an oven mitt or other heat protectant glove.
  4. Place your desired portion of pizza onto the hot pan, returning it to the oven.
  5. Allow to cook for about ten minutes, or longer if you want the crust to become slightly crispy.
  6. Use caution when removing the pizza and do not eat it before it has cooled slightly for about three to five minutes.

Reheating A Deep Dish Pizza In The Toaster Oven

The toaster oven is an easy and quick method to reheat deep dish pizza. When you don’t have access to an oven, this is a great alternative to get the job done. 

The only reason some may choose not to reheat a deep dish pizza in the oven is having to wait for it to preheat. The toaster oven preheats in a fraction of the time, making it a great method to use when you are in a rush or trying to eat your pizza on the go.

The only drawback to the toaster oven in comparison to the oven is that you cannot fit more than two to three slices inside at a time. If you are looking to reheat more than that, this is probably not the best method to use.

If you want a faster heating method but still want to conserve that quality taste and texture, give the toaster oven a try by following these steps:

  1. Preheat your toaster oven to 325 degrees fahrenheit on the “warm” setting.
  2. Place your deep dish pizza slice or slices directly on the rack of the toaster oven, or onto a piece of aluminum foil. 
  3. Allow to cook for about 5-10 minutes, until heated through.
  4. Carefully remove the deep dish pizza from the toaster oven, allowing it to cool for about two minutes before enjoying.

Reheating A Deep Dish Pizza In The Microwave

Sometimes you may not have access to a toaster oven or conventional oven to reheat your deep dish pizza, such as in the office or in a hotel room. If this is the case, you can still enjoy your hot and mouthwatering slice in a matter of no time. 

Related Posts  Can You Reheat a Fried Egg? Here Are 2 Simple Ways to Do It

The only drawback to reheating deep dish pizza in the microwave is you cannot do more than one or two slices at a time. When preparing more than that, the microwave is not the most efficient method to do so. Consider using the oven instead for larger portions. 

If you are looking to reheat your deep dish pizza as quickly as you possibly can, the microwave method is the one for you. Microwaving allows you to reheat your deep dish pizza in the smallest amount of time while still preserving the delicious taste that you’re waiting to enjoy. 

To reheat your deep dish pizza in the microwave, follow these steps:

  1. Place your desired amount of pizza slices on a microwave safe dish.
  2. Make sure your microwave is on the high power level setting.
  3. Place the pizza inside of the microwave and cook for thirty seconds.
  4. Check the temperature of the pizza. If additional time is needed, heat in fifteen second intervals until desired temperature is reached.
  5. Allow to cool for one minute before serving and enjoying.

How To Store Deep Dish Pizza

Storing deep dish pizza is a great way to keep it safe and ready ro the next time you want to dig in. Deep dish pizza must be properly stored to keep it from picking up unwanted bacteria that can cause food borne illness.

Before your deep dish pizza has been at room temperature for two hours, be sure to properly store it. This can be done in either the refrigerator or freezer, depending how long you want to keep it for.

To store your deep dish pizza in the refrigerator, place it in an airtight container or resealable plastic bag with all excess air removed. Place it inside of the refrigerator and keep for up to four days.

If you want to keep your deep dish pizza around longer than just a few days, consider freezing it. This method will keep your deep dish pizza fresh and safe to consume for a longer period of time than storing it in the refrigerator.

To store your deep dish pizza in the freezer, place it in an airtight container or resealable plastic bag with all excess air removed. Keep it in the freezer for up to two months, though it is important to note the more time it is stored the more risk of quality decreasing you have.

Related Posts  How to Reheat Fried Mushrooms: Quick and Easy Tips

If your deep dish pizza has been frozen, be sure to thaw it before reheating. This will help maintain quality and keep your pizza from becoming soggy. 

Deep dish pizza that has been frozen can be thawed safely in the refrigerator. Simply place the amount you are planning to thaw inside of the refrigerator and allow it to thaw overnight. Frozen pizza can also be thawed at room temperature for up to two hours. 

Be sure not to leave frozen pizza out at room temperature for more than two hours. Refrigeration thawing is recommended for pizza that has meat toppings to ensure it remains safe to consume.

In Conclusion

Deep dish pizza may have begun in Chicago, but it has grown to become a staple dish at pizza shops all over. This pizza is a great option for a quick lunch, dinner or snack even a few days later, making it ideal to keep on hand for a few days or even months. 

Deep dish pizza can be reheated as individual slices or as an entire pie to feed more than just a few people. If you have an entire deep dish pizza left over you want to warm back up, don’t hesitate to throw it into your oven and enjoy.

If you just want a quick slice between running from one place to another, microwaving it for less than a minute can keep you full for your errands and tasks for the day. Simply throw it onto a microwave safe plate and pop into the microwave for less than a minute until your deep dish pizza is sizzling hot.

The toaster oven can also reheat your deep dish pizza in a matter of minutes, for a tasty and flavorful meal that doesn’t take much time. This is a great option for when you want oven results without all of the time to obtain them.

Storing your deep dish pizza properly is ideal in making sure it is safe to consume. In the refrigerator your deep dish pizza is good for four days, but in the freezer it can be good for up to two whole months. 

However you choose to reheat your deep dish pizza, it will be nothing short of delicious and satisfying. Choose the method that works best for you and enjoy the flavor of deep dish pizza for even longer than just one meal.