5 Substitutes for Tiger Sauce

Are you looking for a replacement for tiger sauce? Well, there are several options you can choose from!

Cajun seasoning, pickapeppa sauce, hot sauce and honey, sweet chili sauce, and homemade tiger sauce are all great options to use as substitutes for tiger sauce.

Whether you’re looking for a sauce to use to glaze some vegetables for grilling or to dip your snacks in, there are multiple substitutes you can use! Each is a little different and offers various benefits to your recipes. 

What is tiger sauce?

Tiger sauce is a spicy sauce that is a mixture of sweet and sour. With ingredients like cayenne pepper, vinegar, oregano, red peppers, and cumin, this is a popular choice of sauce for many foods. 

Tiger sauce originates from Louisiana and is easily found in many stores today.

Labeled as “hot and sweet,” this sauce is used on many different types of food and is a great addition to many dishes and snacks. It’s generally considered a light to medium level of spice, but will vary depending on the dish it is used in.

No products found.

What can you use it for?

This sauce is very versatile and can be used for a number of different foods. Some common uses are

  • Chicken
  • Steak
  • Fish
  • Sandwiches
  • Soups
  • Dips

Tiger Sauce Substitues

1. Cajun seasoning

Cajun seasoning makes a good replacement for tiger sauce in many dishes. 

Related Posts  6 Sweet Potato Flour Substitutes

This seasoning uses paprika, garlic powder, cayenne pepper, and onion powder. It gives your food some heat and delicious flavor, and if you don’t have tiger sauce in your pantry, this is a great alternative!

2. Pickapeppa sauce

Another good alternative to tiger sauce is pickapeppa sauce. It has a ketchup-like consistency and is sometimes referred to as “Jamaican ketchup.”

This sauce contains vinegar, sugar, mango, red peppers, and white raisins as ingredients. This lends to the exotic flavor that is reminiscent of tiger sauce.

Pickapeppa sauce has a good amount of heat to it and will add some spice to your food. It also has a sweet aftertaste much like tiger sauce, which makes this a good substitute.

No products found.

3. Honey and hot sauce

If you don’t have time to run to the store, you can make a replacement for tiger sauce yourself with products you probably already have at home.

Use a hot sauce like tabasco or even siracha and mix in some honey. This will give it the “hot and sweet” taste that’s expected from tiger sauce. 

This alternative is great in a pinch but probably won’t give you the delicious, exotic flavor of tiger sauce. 

4. Sweet chili sauce

Sweet chili cause is another product you can use as a substitute for tiger sauce. It will provide a sweet and spicy taste similar to tiger sauce. Plus, this product is available in most stores and is easy to find.

This alternative will most likely be a bit sweeter than what is expected from tiger sauce, so keep that in mind when trying out this suggestion. It will also not offer as much heat as you’ll find in tiger sauce. In some dishes, this could make for an even tastier end result!

Related Posts  9 Spam Alternatives

No products found.

5. Homemade tiger sauce

If you aren’t pressed for time, try making your own tiger sauce! This is a creative way to replace tiger sauce in your dish.

One benefit of this alternative is that you can add or remove any ingredients that you like or dislike, or that would be beneficial or take away from your dish.

There are many different recipes to find online, or you can try to make one yourself. Try adding some cayenne pepper to some corn syrup or honey and go from there!


Tiger sauce is a delicious sauce used in many different recipes. However, if you need to replace this ingredient or are looking to try something new, there are a few different things you can try!

If you’re looking for less heat or even want to try to make it yourself, there’s an option for you! It’s always exciting to branch out and try something new and a great way to do that is by trying out some of these tiger sauce substitutions!