How To Make Uncrustables Thaw Faster

If you’re looking for an easy, yummy treat, Smucker’s Uncrustables are hard to beat. These frozen sandwiches come in a variety of flavors, like peanut butter and jelly, chocolate hazelnut spread, or peanut butter and honey.

The downside of Uncrustables sandwiches is that they can take some time to thaw out. If you’re hungry and want to eat right away, you’re probably wondering how you make Uncrustables thaw faster.

The safest options to make your packaged sandwich thaw faster is to rub it between your hands, place it in the sunlight, or dunk it in a bowl of warm water.

Can you thaw Uncrustables in the microwave?

While the microwave might seem like the most convenient method, Smucker’s advises against it. This is because the filling tends to heat up more quickly than the bread, so it can be hard to tell when the sandwich is just too hot to eat. The outside stays cool to the touch, but the filling inside can potentially burn you.

To be safe, use the methods mentioned above instead. According to the packaging, Uncrustables sandwiches should be thawed at room temperature for 30 to 60 minutes. You can speed up the process by:

  • Using your body heat to warm the sandwich faster by rubbing it between your hands
  • Taking advantage of the natural heat of the sunlight by placing the sandwich in a warm location
  • Dunking the packaged sandwich in a bowl of warm water until completely thawed
Related Posts  How Do You Thaw Frozen Spinach?

How long can Uncrustables be left out of the freezer?

Smucker’s recommends that Uncrustables thawed at room temperature be eaten within six to eight hours for maximum freshness. You could also opt to thaw your sandwich in your fridge, which gives you up to 24 hours to eat it.

No matter how you thaw it, you should always eat your Uncrustables sandwich as soon as possible to prevent any risk of contamination by bacteria.


Defrosting your Uncrustables sandwich doesn’t have to be a hassle! By following these simple steps, you can enjoy your sandwich in no time.