11 Oxtail Substitutes with the Same Unique Beef-Like Flavor

Oxtail is an extremely rare type of meat. With its scarcity, comes an expensive price tag. It used to be the tail of oxen, but nowadays oxtail is just the tail of beef cattle. It can come from either gender of cow, and is sometimes also veal.

Before preparation, an oxtail weighs around eight pounds. The tail has a high amount of collagen, making it rich in gelatin. To be sold, an oxtail is skinned and cut into pieces, which are different sizes because the tail narrows as it gets closer to the end.

Oxtail is a wonderful delicacy, but it’s no surprise that it isn’t really accessible for many people. At least, not for a casual dinner. If you want to enjoy something similar to oxtail, you have plenty of options. Because oxtail is a type of beef, other types of beef can suffice in its place.

Some of the best oxtail substitutes are beef neck bones, beef shank, beef tendon, chucks, cheeks, and short ribs. A similar flavor to oxtail can also be found in lamb neck bones and shanks. There are even some vegan options for oxtail substitutes.

Is Oxtail a Good Meat?

Oxtail is a pretty healthy red meat. It is incredibly rich in collagen, which is an essential protein to keep our bodies in good shape. Oxtail is over 70% fat, meaning those on ketogenic or paleo diets can consume it. 

One serving of oxtail also contains two-thirds of the recommended daily protein intake. It is still a red meat, however, and has saturated fats and cholesterol. Oxtails are also very useful. They are bony and don’t have much meat, so they are perfect for making bone broth. 

Beef Oxtail Step 1
  • Meets standards for animal welfare, feed, and more, so you can know about what you’re buying (and eating)
  • No added growth hormones or antibiotics, ever
  • No animal by-products in feed
  • Traceable to farm or ranch.
  • Animal Welfare Certified by Global Animal Partnership

Why is Oxtail So Tasty?

The taste of oxtail is complex. It is comparable to beef (as oxtail comes from a cow, like beef), but more tender. Its texture is similar to that of beef short ribs, and is often described as silky. The gelatinous, richness of oxtail makes it an easily craveable meat.

What Can I Substitute for Oxtail?

While oxtail itself is somewhat rare and rather expensive, there are other foods which have a similar flavor or texture, and thus can be substituted for it. Below are some of the best substitutes for oxtail.

Related Posts  What Can I Substitute for Lemon Extract? Try These 8 Things Instead

Beef Based

1. Beef Neck Bones

Beef neck bones are going to be much easier to track down than oxtail. The tendons of beef neck bones can also be found in the tail, so it is a sufficient substitute. Beef neck bones are also much less expensive than oxtail.

Their texture is still tender when cooked, but they have a much lower fat content. Beef neck bones can be used in any situation that you would use oxtail, or beef, for that matter. They are super easy to work with and can be added straight into a boiling pot of water for stew.

2. Beef Shank

Beef shank comes from the leg of a heifer or steer (female or male cow that has not given birth and is relatively young). Cattle use their legs often, so beef shank is dry and rough in texture. Because of this, it requires a longer cooking time than other types of beef.

Beef shank is often the type of meat that is used to produce ground beef. It must be cooked on a moist heat, so as to not dry it out further. You probably won’t be able to get it at a butcher shop, but it is widely available and affordable at grocery stores. 

3. Beef Short Ribs

Beef short ribs can be cut from the chuck, brisket, or plate parts of the cattle. Short ribs have a bone attached to them, so they come in either English or flanken cut. Beef short ribs can easily replace oxtail in nearly any recipe that calls for it. 

Natural Angus Prime Rib by Nebraska Star Beef – All Natural Hand Cut and Trimmed and Great with Steak Rub – Steaks for Delivery to Your Home
  • Holiday Dinner Done Right – Nothing beats a prime rib and our natural angus prime rib is a favorite around the holidays and at 10 lbs it will feed 8 to 12 family members
  • The Perfect Cut; This prime rib is a well marbled and tender and juicy rib roasts dry aged for 35 days or more for the most delicious flavor
  • Enhance with our Horseradish Prime Rib Rub; This rub which is sold separately goes with steak like peas go with carrots because it is a classic designed to add an accent to the flavor of a steak
  • Tradition and Excellence; Raised and aged and butchered the traditional way which is hand cut and trimmed one at a time and is the absolute highest quality humanely raised and antibiotic free and hormone free
  • We believe in providing healthy products that are antibiotic and hormone free for families. We believe in modern technology and conveniences such as online ordering with steaks arriving at your door

4. Beef Tendon

When making soups and stews, beef tendon is a perfect substitute for oxtail. Like oxtail, beef tendons are very gelatinous and firm, but they tend to be richer in flavor. Beef tendon is best when simmered, because the juiciness of it will be extracted and it will add a pungent flavor to your dish. 

Related Posts  Best Substitute for Nagaimo: Top Alternatives to Enhance Your Dishes

5. Beef Cheeks

The flavor of beef cheeks can easily be equated to that of oxtail. The meat of beef cheeks also has a very concentrated gelatin content, which melts off wonderfully. It will seep into the rest of your dish, creating a perfect umami flavor. 

6. Beef Chuck

For any dish that has to do with beef, consider beef chuck as an oxtail replacement. It is the largest cut of cattle, and is also a type of steak. Because beef chuck usually comes from the meatiest part of the cattle, it is high in protein and many vitamins and minerals.

One serving of beef chuck contains vitamin D, and is full of other minerals. Some of these include calcium, iron, magnesium, phosphorus, and potassium, to name a few. It is also pretty low in fat, considering the rest of its health value.

Lamb Based

7. Lamb Neck Bones

Lamb neck bones are, as the name suggests, a portion of lamb containing bone. The bones are covered in a layer of fat which is firm, but becomes tender when cooked properly. When simmered or stewed, lamb neck bones can easily produce as much gelatin as oxtail.

The flavor of lamb neck bones is meaty and strong, making them suitable for a wide variety of dishes. They are great for slow-cooking, and are also a good addition to soups and stews. Overall, lamb neck bones will give a new, fresh, flavor to essentially any recipe.

8. Lamb Shanks

Lamb shanks are very similar to beef shanks, so it only makes sense that they would also belong on a list of oxtail substitutes. The shanks of lamb are rich in tendons and fats, which allows them to add a mouth-watering taste to whatever dish they are added to.

When cooked properly (on low heat and slowly), the texture of lamb shanks becomes juicy and tender. There are a couple types of shanks, but they virtually taste the same in the end. The foreshank is from the front legs and is smaller than the hind shank, which is derived from the animal’s back legs and is much meatier.

Lamb Hind Shanks – 2 pack – approx. 2.5 lb / 1.1 kg – GUARANTEED OVERNIGHT
  • The lamb shank is known to be one of the most flavorful cuts of lamb. The best way to prepare lamb shanks is by braising them.
  • o ensure the best tasting lamb shanks, they need to be cooked over low heat for a long time in order to reveal their smooth texture, full flavor, and fall-off-the-bone juiciness.
  • These bone-in hind shanks are removed from the lamb leg by a straight knife cut through the stifle joint, the knuckle tip is removed.

Meatless Plant-Based

Believe it or not, the taste of oxtail can also be replicated with plants. This will be very helpful for those who follow a vegan diet, but the similarities to oxtail that can come from mushrooms or jackfruit are certainly shocking to seasoned meat lovers.

Related Posts  Arrowroot Starch Substitutes: A Guide to Alternatives for Gluten-Free Cooking

9. Seitan

If you’ve ever researched a vegan alternative to any sort of meat, you’ve likely come across seitan as a recommendation. This is because its texture and taste were made to replicate that of regular meats. When cooked, it’s hard to tell the difference. 

Seitan is made from gluten, which is the stringy protein used in dough. It’s what makes dough stretchy. But for seitan, the starch is removed, so it is basically pure gluten. Most other plant-based meat replacements are made from soy, so this is how seitan sets itself apart, and becomes an almost-exact meat replica.

10. Portobello Mushroom

It’s no secret that the flavor of portobello mushrooms is complex. Combined with their tough, chewy, texture, these mushrooms can make for a good meat substitute. The aroma they give off is similar to beef, and they will also add a deeper flavor to your recipes.

Try using portobello mushrooms in place of oxtail in casseroles, stews, and soups, to get a hint of the beefy flavor that we know and love oxtail for. They are also low in calories, making them great for those who may be trying to lose weight. 

11. Jackfruit

Jackfruit makes for an excellent meat substitute, in almost any case, including for oxtail. Unripe jackfruit has a meaty and stringy texture that is similar to meat. It is the most similar to pulled pork or beef. In fact, jackfruit can be used in place of meat in any recipe that calls for shredded, ground, or pulled meat, making it incredibly versatile.

The fruit also has a very neutral taste, like most meats do. Because of this, it’s an easy meat replacement that can cater to whatever flavors it’s added to. Some say its flavor when cooked is strikingly similar to pulled pork.

Native Forest Organic Young Jackfruit – Great Meatless Alternative, Plant Based Meat, Non-GMO Project Verified, USDA Organic – Original, 14 Oz (Pack of 6)
  • MEATLESS ALTERNATIVE: Our Organic Young Jackfruit is an excellent vegan, soy & gluten free meatless alternative to use in numerous recipes. A mild flavor makes it a great base for sauces & seasonings!
  • GREAT ALTERNATIVE TO CHICKEN & PORK: Young jackfruit’s fleshy interior has a meaty texture similar to chicken. As it cooks, it flakes & shreds making it ideal for vegan pulled pork and chicken recipes.
  • SUSTAINABLY FARMED: We support organic & sustainable farming that avoids GMOs & pesticides. We’re proud participants in the Non-GMO Project & want our consumers to know where their food comes from.
  • SUPPORT FOR SPECIAL DIETS: Our vegetarian products are ethically sourced & suitable for many special diets including vegan, gluten free, paleo, keto, kosher, organic & low sodium.
  • OUR COMMITMENT TO HEALTHY OPTIONS: Our company was born out of a commitment to create delicious & healthy vegetarian foods with convenient preparation for those with busy, health-aware lifestyles.

What Can I Use Instead of Oxtail for Kare Kare?

For kare kare, the best oxtail substitute is beef shin or beef chuck. If you go to a butcher and have them cut it into smaller pieces, it will give the desired effect for kare kare. Some other options for a more mild taste include chicken or pig’s feet.

Any of these options will add the umami flavor that you’re looking for. It may not be oxtail, but it sure gets pretty close. Beef neck bones or short ribs can also work, as they have a high amount of collagen as well. Just be sure that it’s cut into smaller pieces if needed.

Related Questions

Is Oxtail a Lamb or Beef?

Originally, many years ago, oxtail came from the tail of an ox (male working cow), hence the name. Nowadays, it is simply the tail of cattle, and can come from either sex. Even though it’s strayed slightly from its original name, oxtail is still beef.

How Do You Eat Oxtails?

Oxtails are very bony, so they are always ideal for stews and soups. Being cooked slowly helps absorb the gelatin to get the most out of oxtails. They can also be braised, often in a liquid like red wine.

Oxtails are debatably the least versatile part of beef, but are also the most flavorful. If you’re making beef stew, oxtail will give it a dramatic and juicy taste.

Is Oxtail the Same as Short Rib?

Although they can be used interchangeably in many cases, oxtail and short rib are not the same. For one, they come from completely different parts of the cattle. Oxtail is also far superior for soups and stews, as it sheds much easier.

Oxtail is also extremely gelatinous and fatty, giving it its signature juiciness. Short ribs are somewhat juicy as well, but the closest match to oxtail is beef cheeks, not short rib.

Final Thoughts  

Oxtail is a decadent meat, but unfortunately it has risen in price in the last decade. It has become more of a scarcity, which may leave people wondering what they can use instead of oxtail. Fortunately, there are many sufficient replacements which are often both easier to find and cheaper in cost.